(The following analysis is based on the draft of Waxman-Markey released in March 2009.)
The EIA (Energy Information Administration) has released its modeling on the cost of the federal RES currently proposed in the Waxman-Markey legislation, also known as the American Clean Energy and Security (ACES) Act.
High points from EIA’s Executive Summary:
- The baseline for the analysis is based on the economic/ renewable energy impacts of the America Recovery and Reinvestment Act (ARRA, ie, recovery funds from the economic stimulus package) – the ARRA policies and funds basically jump start the RES.
- While the RES target is officially 25% by 2025, various exemptions will actually lower this target:
- Exemptions for small retailers = 22% by 2025
- Hydro and muni solid waste removed from targets = 21% by 2025
- Energy efficiency credits (similar to RECs) = 17% by 2025
- Wind and biomass will be key fuels in
meeting RES, solar and geothermal will ramp up significantly. The
projected increase in wind development is actually due to ARRA
incentives and state level RES’s (amazingly). Increased renewables will
lead to lower coal and gas generation, and lower carbon dioxide
emissions from the electricity sector.
- The national RES will not affect
electricity prices until after 2020, and the peak effect will be less
than 3% nationally. By 2030, this increase will go back down to less
than 1%.
- Regionally, electricity prices will
vary – the Great Plains and the northwest states will see price
declines, and other regions could see price increases of 1-6%.
- NOTE: The RES modeling did not take
into account other provisions of ACES, such as the cap and trade or
the Energy Efficiency Resource Standard (EERS).
- Cap and trade could decrease compliance costs of the RES
- If an EERS led to significant decrease in demand, that might make it hard to build new renewable capacity
- Unknowns in the
analysis: Future prices of fossil fuels (high prices = good for
renewables, low prices = bad), the future for biomass conversion at
existing coal-fired power plants, and how fast developers can build
transmission lines to get renewables to market.
|